Andrea Pritzker, Third Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“Mocha cedar, chinotto aromas unfold to reveal a juicy and savoury palate with fine tannins, just falling away slightly on the finish. When paired with the venison the wine seemed both more juicy but also more chalky.”
Warren Gibson, First Term Chairman of Judges, Eleventh Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“Charry, lifted and pure. Very complex, plenty of fruit and other complexities in the background. Some firmness pokes through on the palate with the dish”
Corey Ryan, Second Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“Brooding dark cherry, dank wintergreen notes, wet forest-floor undertones. Some oak nuances flinty spice chewy rounded great acid line texture. Sweet fleshy red fruits well textured rounded wine. The complexity of the wine is promoted by the dish. The shallot gravy lifts the wines herbal the acidity and subtle tannins working well with the venison texture.”
Stuart James Halliday, Fourth Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“A little more stalky on the palate, with some drying savoury tannins, slight chewiness at the end. The sweet/savoury nature of the dish really lifts the wine”
Susan Bastian, Fifth Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“Mid garnet red. Blue flowers, red fruits and parsnip aromas. Delicate red fruits on plate with very silky tannin. This match does not quote work as it exacerbates wine tannin.”
Mark Robertson, Eighth Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“Darker brooding nose. Black fruits, DMS driven, matchy and forthright. Palate structured and blocky. Not veering into Dry Red but close. Ripe wine that still retains pinot ness. Not bad. With Food ? great. Spicy stalky palate really works well. Structure enhances fruit on the finish.”
The Pinot Noir Wines were judged with
Presented by chef Marcell Kustos
Ingredients
Shallot gravy
Method
Stephen Wong, Second Term Panellist 2019 Competition
“A generous, decadent and voluptuous style of Pinot; sweet cinnamon oak, ripe Black Doris plum and black cherry flavours abound. Mouth-filling, creamy and fruit-driven, the palate is held in check by some late dark chocolate flavours which adds a welcome touch of balance. The sweet fruit style doesn?t really work with venison - duck would have been better.”